Product Pricing Strategies: The Cons of List Pricing

PROS, Inc. is a leading provider of SaaS solutions that optimize omnichannel shopping and selling experiences, powering intelligent commerce.

Key Takeaways

  • List pricing assumes negotiation: Ineffective for self-serve eCommerce buyers.
  • Cost fluctuations: Traditional pricing can’t keep up with market changes.
  • High list prices deter buyers: Leads to lost trust and market share.
  • Dynamic pricing benefits: Tailored, competitive, and profitability-focused.
  • Iterative approach: Measure, learn, and adjust pricing strategies.

Over 62% of enterprise B2B companies expect eCommerce to be their dominant sales channel in the next five years. And with that, more than 50% of their business will transact with little or no help from a sales professional.

In this new environment of self-serve business transactions, delivering the right price, every time, is critical. Yet most B2B companies have maintained list pricing as part of their core product pricing strategy, which falls short of delivering the right price in the eCommerce world.

Why Do Product Pricing Strategies Fall Short?


List prices are reference points for beginning sales negotiations, primarily derived in either of two ways:

  • The estimated end consumer price, such as the price of a brake pad in the store.
  • A cost-plus price where the price increases with every vendor cost increase but does not necessarily adjust in times of vendor cost reduction.

As B2B enterprises rely more on eCommerce and omni-channel sales strategies, list pricing strategies fall short. But why?

List product pricing strategies assume negotiation

In the self-serve eCommerce channel, the negotiation aspect of the sale is taken away. Remember, a key principle of a list product pricing strategy is to set great prices to begin a negotiation. To make a quick transition to capturing the online market, many businesses make the mistake of using one of their catalog prices for their online product catalog. The savvy buyer is very quickly turned away, since it is not in the ballpark of a realistic price.

Costs are fluctuating at a higher rate than ever before

Cost fluctuations mean higher end-consumer prices. One of the reasons for fluctuations is changing business models. Fewer buyers are willing to get locked into the terms of a three-year contract, or all-you-can-eat licenses.

The preference is to reduce the risk of the purchase by leveraging subscriptions (pay as you go) to achieve better alignment to value received. Traditional list pricing practices of biannual and even quarterly mass price updates are simply not frequent enough; these prices are out of date the day after publishing.

High non-negotiated list prices imply a direct loss of business

Implied loss of business can curtail market share growth of new customers and business. The negative impact is compounded by the inability to react to the market fast enough. This affects the buyer’s perception of the vendor’s ability to do business, causing a loss in trust and driving them to look for other vendors.

How can B2B companies leverage a smart dynamic pricing strategy as a driving factor for omni-channel success?  In order to stay ahead, companies will need to move away from list pricing and adopt different product pricing strategies.

Ensure Prices are Tailored and Non-Negotiable

Ensure that prices are tailored for every unique customer interaction with the important assumption that no negotiation will take place. This will serve today’s modern buyers, who are choosing self-serve channels because they want the fastest way to order their products and services.

How? Pre-calculating the near-infinite number of potential interactions is not the answer. It is a waste of expensive time and storage, since a high percentage of these generated prices will never be used. Let’s explore a practical approach for a dynamic pricing strategy.

The foundation is established by setting up pricing rules based on three main inputs of your dynamic pricing strategy:

Value to Buyer

Use a price optimization algorithm to ensure the value of the product to the buyer has been accurately captured.

  • Based on historic purchase patterns, it is possible to cluster customers together based on their price elasticity for a product, while capturing seasonality and external market trends.
  • Using this method, businesses can easily identify customers buying below the segment’s average price, given the overall value perception of the product to the customer segment.
  • This ensures that the price can be adjusted based on the customer’s buying conditions, such as packaging or region of purchase.

Competitive Landscape

Set up rules to ensure you are within relative range to your competition.

  • Overlaying value-based pricing with captured market conditions ensures that the pricing is always relevant.
  • Competitive data is easier to attain due to eCommerce web scraping. The accuracy of this data is improving due to simplified pricing with limited hidden rebates.
  • These pricing rules ensure the price is always within a range of your main competitors. This does not simply follow competitive price fluctuations, but instead keeps prices within a reasonable range to ensure your offering is always in the race.

Profitability

Set up rules to ensure you are maintaining the expected profitability of your product lines.

  • Analytics based on historical transactions ensure that you have a clear understanding of the profitability waterfall.
  • This input is based on your business strategy, ensuring that every product line and region is within range of the prescribed profitability.

Establish processes to measure and learn

Long-term dynamic pricing success requires an iterative process to measure, learn and adjust. For example, there are going to be situations where competition is undercutting your revenue and profitability. Monitoring abandoned carts, market trends and relationships are important to ensure that you are relaxing or tightening your rules on a periodic basis. This iterative approach will help your business stay close to the changing needs of buyers.

Deliver across all sales channels

Delivering dynamic pricing strategies across all sales channels is key. Ensure that your organization invests in tools that can provide the capabilities of a real-time pricing engine. This further ensures that you are not only providing the right price to your eCommerce channel, but that these prices are harmonized across all your sales channels.

What is the Smartest Price Strategy for You?

The right solution always starts with defining an end goal and a strategy to feed that goal. If your long-term vision includes driving share through eCommerce, consider whether you’re taking the right steps today to get there. Start small, e.g. focus on your most volatile products, where end consumers are more accepting of price fluctuations. Create a tailored pricing structure, such as the one mentioned above for one of your product lines. Measure the success rates, learn from the outcomes, iterate and expand!

Potential customers are trolling your website as you read this article, but are they buying from you?

Frequently Asked Questions

Why does list pricing fail in eCommerce?

List pricing assumes negotiation, which is absent in self-serve eCommerce, making it unsuitable for modern buyers seeking quick, realistic prices. 

What are the risks of high list prices?

High list prices can deter buyers, erode trust, and result in lost market share, especially when prices are outdated or uncompetitive. 

How does dynamic pricing address cost fluctuations?

Dynamic pricing uses real-time data and algorithms to adjust prices based on market trends, price elasticity, and cost changes. 

What inputs are essential for dynamic pricing?

Dynamic pricing relies on value to the buyer, competitive landscape, and profitability rules to ensure tailored and effective pricing. 

How can businesses transition from list pricing to dynamic pricing?

Start with volatile products, set tailored pricing rules, measure outcomes, and iterate to expand dynamic pricing across all channels. 

Why is tailored pricing important for B2B buyers?

Tailored pricing aligns with customer-specific needs, improving satisfaction and loyalty while maximizing revenue opportunities. 

What tools support dynamic pricing strategies?

Real-time pricing engines and price optimization software enable businesses to deliver consistent, competitive, and profitable prices across channels. 

Other content in this Stream

Confirmed: ChatGPT Is a Higher-Intent Channel Than Google (For Airlines)

Does ChatGPT drive more qualified traffic than Google? A new study of 80 airlines says yes, revealing a substantially higher booking intent. Read the analysis.

Airline RetailingBlog

PROS Platform Travel Release: What’s New for Fall 2025

Explore highlights from the PROS Travel Platform Fall 2025 Release, designed to help airlines deliver offers with greater precision, control, and profitability.

BlogPlatform Releases

PROS Platform: What’s New for Fall 2025

Discover the latest updates in the PROS B2B Platform Fall 2025 release, including smarter pricing tools, enhanced CPQ features, and advanced analytics to streamline workflows and boost productivity.

BlogPlatform Releases

Winning the Citation War: The Airline Playbook for AI Search

AI Search for Airlines. Boost airline brand visibility and win citations across AI Search ecosystems like ChatGPT, Google AI Mode, and Classic Search with these six tactics.

Airline RetailingBlog

Japan Airlines Boosts Group Sales Revenue 3X With PROS

Discover how Japan Airlines (JAL) boosted group sales revenue by 3X, reduced manual tasks by 90%, and increased market share by 20% with PROS Group Sales Optimizer. Learn how automation and dynamic pricing transformed their global group sales strategy.

BlogCase Studies & Testimonials